When Love Is Just a Fantasy: 6 Signs You’re Not in the Real Thing
It’s easy to fall in love with someone… or at least, the idea of them. Especially when we’re lonely, healing, or just tired of starting over. But what if what we’re calling “love” is really just a story we’ve told ourselves? One that feels good, but isn’t real?
Let’s talk about the quiet ways we confuse fantasy for love and why so many of us stay in that situation for too long.
1. We fall for potential, not reality.
You might see someone and think, “They could be amazing if they just opened up more… got their life together… healed.” So you stay, hoping they’ll grow into the version you see in your head. But the truth? Love isn’t about holding out for who someone might become. It’s about seeing them clearly as they are today and still choosing them.
2. We cling to the highs and ignore the lows.
Those first few weeks when they made you feel seen? The long convos, late-night talks, that one weekend you felt totally connected? That version of them gets replayed in your mind every time something feels off. Even when the rest of the relationship feels cold, confusing, or inconsistent. Love isn’t just about the peak moments, it’s about who they are on an average Tuesday, too.
3. We want the story to work more than we want the truth.
You’ve already introduced them to friends. You’ve made future plans in your head. So even when it’s not working, it’s hard to let go. Because letting go feels like failure. But staying in something just because you’ve invested time? That’s not love, it’s fear wearing a mask.
4. We confuse attention with affection.
They text back. They like your posts. They flirt just enough to keep the thread going. But do they really see you? Do they show up when it matters? A few breadcrumbs can feel like a feast when you’re emotionally starving, but real love nourishes you. It doesn’t leave you constantly questioning where you stand.
5. We feel seen... because they trigger our wounds.
Sometimes we mistake emotional intensity for connection. They remind us of someone from our past, and we call it chemistry. But it might just be familiarity, your nervous system reacting to old pain. If chaos feels like home, a calm, respectful love can feel boring at first. But that quiet safety? That’s where the real connection lives.
6. We mistake being needed for being loved.
You’re always the one fixing things, holding space, making it work. You feel important, but also drained. When you’re used to proving your worth by how much you give, someone needing you can feel like love. But love doesn’t demand your exhaustion. It holds space for your needs, too.
The truth is, fantasy feels safe until it doesn’t.
Real love requires presence, honesty, and mutual effort. It won’t always look like the movies. Sometimes it’s slow and steady. Sometimes it’s quiet. But it won’t leave you questioning your worth. If you’re starting to wonder whether you’ve been falling for the idea of someone rather than who they truly are, you’re not alone and you’re not broken. It just means you’re waking up.
If you’re wondering where you really stand, try our free “Am I Ready for Love?” quiz, it only takes a minute and might just give you the clarity you’ve been looking for.
Want more support on this? Sign up for free to our newsletter, this week’s topic is all about How to Tell If You’re In Love or Just in Delusion. (Click the box below)